Last night I went to hear Tom Regan speak, who is an animal rights activist and author of Empty Cages: Facing the Challenge of Animal Rights and The Case for Animal Rights, among others.
I went with the famous Myria and Nate. Tom Regan had a lot of interesting things to say. During his main presentation he talked about many issues that I had already given a lot of though to. But it was interesting to hear his arguments, and it helped me to fill in the gaps in my own arguments.
During the question and answer session, some very good questions were raised, two of which by the afore mentioned famous Myria and Nate. One question was how did Mr. Regan feel about PETA being the face of the animal rights movement. Tom basically said it was a mixed bag. Sometimes PETA does some really good things, like their undercover investigations in to animal cruelty in labs and testing facilities. But of course they also do a lot of things that make the movement look very stupid. I think he summed it up as, “PETA, that’s not really where it’s at.”
Another good question that was raised was, how did Mr. Regan feel about those who though were vegan or vegetarian, but not activists. This question, and Tom’s answer, got me thinking the most. Regan basically said that if you’re not working to expand the movement, the you’re not really in the movement. I wasn’t aware of it completely up until that point, but I have conflicting views about reducing the amount of cruelty in the world. Part of me views being vegan as a lifestyle and the other part of me views it as a movement. Ultimately, I can’t have it both ways.
On some level I think I’ve always thought of myself as an inactivist. It’s not about what I do that’s important, it’s about what I don’t do, what I choose not to be a part of. And I still think there is some merit there, but the more I think about what Tom Regan said about expanding the movement, the more it makes sense. The more people who are against cruelty to animals (and people) the less cruelty there will be.
So I’ve decided to be more vocal and visible about being vegan. I don’t believe that pressuring people is an effective way of changing people’s minds. Guilt trips or intimidation can cause some to change their lifestyles, but usually the end result is not sincere. If people don’t come to the conclusion largely on their own to change their ways, then the changes will most likely not last. So me becoming more vocal and visible does not mean I’m going to start acting like and angry activist stereo-type. It does mean that I am going to talk about being vegan, something I rarely have done in the past. And when given the opportunity, I’ll debate the issues that surround animal rights and cruelty. Generally, I want to encourage others to think about the cruelty that is involved in all of our day to day lives and how we work to reduce it.